Antigone Paper

Eliot Hart Nelson
Ms. Peifer
10 IB Hour 4
26 November, 2008

Unscrupulous Leader, Immoral Decision

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, family is a delicate but important institution. Without a strong sense of family one is left to wander the perils of mortal life alone, desperate for a source of comfort. No one should stand between two family members in a time of personal grief. But, unfortunately, that is precisely what Creon did. After the death of Polynices, Creon rashly ordered that his body should not receive a proper burial and should alternatively be left to be eaten by carrion animals. Such spiteful vengeance is disgusting and unbecoming in a leader. Creon's judgement overstepped his bounds and ended the lives of 3 of his loved ones, and because of this he is guilty.

First, let's address the issue of Creon's morality. He claims to be a fair, unbiased ruler,  "For me, a man who rules the entire state and does not take the best advice there is, but through fear keeps his mouth forever shut,  such a man is the very worst of men." (Sophocles, 202-205). Yet he takes no council and rules from his gut when judging Polynices, "Don’t yield to those who contravene my orders." (251).  Such inconsistency and hypocrisy is unacceptable in such a powerful position. If Creon is unable to keep his word, he is unfit to lead.

Next, there is the matter of the effectiveness of Creon's actions. One would assume that he made the controversial ruling because it would better his region, but it had the opposite effect. Antigone, Haemon, and Euridice all committed suicide and the royal family was thrown into ruin. Even Creon's followers admit that these terrible deaths are his fault, "a clear reminder that this evil come not from some stranger, but his own mistakes."(1259-1260). This leaves no excuse for Creon's conduct.

And finally, let us look at Creon's guilt. After the death of his son he renounces his innocence and accepts the fated outcomes of his deeds, "You see us here, all in one family, the killer and the killed. Oh the profanity of what I planned." (1418-1420). Even Creon himself realizes the magnitude of his mistake, so much so that he concedes that he is to blame.

Why should we give this second thought? Creon made an careless decision on shaky moral ground, and by doing so practically wiped out the entire royal family. He is a liar and a murderer, and Creon's despicable judgement is an indicator of what more is to come under his rule. If this jury is of conscious mind, it will make the only right choice: guilty.

Works Cited

Sophocles. “Antigone.” Sophocles Antigone. Trans. Ian Johnston. 9 Aug. 2008. Vancouver Island University Malaspira. November      26,2008.

Antigone LRJ#2

Imagery very important in Antigone. It expresses themes and undertones that help the reader further understand the intentions of each character. Much imagery can be seen in the monologues of Teiresias, the prophet. He uses very descriptive and symbolic language in his rants to Creon, where he describes a vision he had involving two birds, "Tearing each other, dying in a whirlwind of wings and clashing." (Sophocles, 836). This detail not only describes the literal vision but also contributes to the significance of Teiresias' warning. Imagery is also used to set the tone in these speeches, "There was only spattering slime of the fat thigh flesh melting: the entrails dissolved in gray smoke. The bare bones burst from the welter."(836). Teiresias' bleak words hint at Creon's unfavorable fate.

The character that suffered the greatest in this story was, predictably, the character with the largest fatal flaw: Creon. His fatal flaw was arrogance and rashness in his leadership. This can be seen as he gives orders to his guards, "Don’t yield to those who contravene my orders."(line 251). From this it can be seen that Creon is impetuous and over-confident in the morality of his actions. His Peripetia comes when he first lays eyes on Haemon weeping over Anitgone's dead body, "When Creon saw him the tears rushed to his eyes."(840). This is the moment in which his fate is reversed, his actions have lost meaning because Antigone has taken her fate into her own hands. His Anagnorisis occurs when he curses the gods for the death of his son, "The truth is hard to hear. Surely a god has crushed me beneath the hugest weight of heaven."(841). This is when he truly understands the scope of his actions. He now realizes that all those dear to him have taken their lives because of his foolish judgement. This is also when the reader feels an emotional relief, or catharsis. The reader can no longer feel for Creon, his character has finished developing and the consequences of his actions are now apparent. 

Women in Antigone are characterized by their passion and the impact of their actions. This passion can best be seen in the character of Antigone when she denounces Creon's judgement and declares her quest to obtain a proper burial for her brother, "I’ll still bury him. It would be fine to die while doing that. I’ll lie there with him."(lines 89-90). This shows that Antigone's gender does not suppress her urge to fight for justice. Women are also characterized as the cause of suffering. Antigone's suicide is so tragic to Haemon that he too kills himself, "Angry at himself, the ill-fated lad right then and there leaned into his own sword, driving half the blade between his ribs."(lines 1375-1377). In this story, women cause suffering, not by manipulation as in other Greek mythology, but rather their death is the ultimate loss that begins the Anagnorisis and Peripetia.

Works Cited:

Sophocles. "Antigone." Literature Timeless Voices, Timeless Themes: World Literature. Trans. Dudley Fitts and Robert Fitzgerald. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall 2001. 814-826.

Sophocles. "Antigone." Malaspina University-College Website. Trans. Ian Johnston. May 2005.
Malaspina University College. 26 November 2008 .

Scandal in the Royal Family

After the epic dual of Eteocles and Polynices, citizens of Thebes were content to follow the orders of the newly crowned ruler, Creon. Such orders were that Eteocles was to be given an honorable burial, for he died a patriot, but Polynices was to be denied a proper burial. Creon labeled him as a traitor to his homeland and sentenced his corpse to be devoured by carrion animals. We, citizens of Thebes, thought the matter was over and done. Ah, but we were wrong! Yesterday, a thin layer of dirt was found over Polynices' remains. No one knew who would dare defy the kings orders in such a brazen way. But then a guard came forward, claiming to have seen Antigone, daughter of Oedipus and sister to Polynices, burying the body. Most people accused of such a heinous crime would be quick to denounce it, but Antigone spread no blame, saying "I avow it; I make no denial". Now, we ponderous townsmen are left to take sides. Was the maiden Antigone, who was engaged to prince Haimon, simply defending the honor of her family and indeed her people? Or rather was she rashly disobeying the clear orders of a superior? Her judgement, and ours, awaits.

--Elionius Monk, The Thinking Thebes-man

My Brain Hurts

The best part of my Saturday? Sleeping in. I'm a textbook procrastinator/insomniac during the school week and Saturdays are usually best spent hibernating until mid-afternoon and being lethargic and unpleasant for the remainder of the day. But today was different. I was forced to get up bright and early (around 10:30) and haul my cookies down to the Electronic Imaging Center at the  U of M campus in Dinkytown. 

I am part of the control group for a new research project pertaining to children with severe brain injuries as a result of head trauma. In the study, they compare the brain scans and testing results of impaired adolescents with those of uninjured teens like me. The first part of the process was an MRI. I had to lie on my back for about an hour in a claustrophobic white tube while the machine whirred and shook. Though I was wearing headphones and watching Ratatoullie through a mirror/projector system, I couldn't seem to elude the feeling that I was in an escape pod, about to be launched into the vacuum of space. After my scan, I moved into the conference room for about 2 and a half hours of cognitive testing. Most of the tests were pretty tedious (putting blocks in corresponding holes, basic spacial analysis), but some of them were sort of difficult. Like saying the color of the word, not the word itself. Man I suck at that! Also, there was a reflex test to measure my impulse control. I was supposed to press a button when a letter flashed on the screen, but if the letter was 'X' I had to restrain myself. It went a little something like this:

A

(click)

F

(click)

H

(click)

X

(click) oh wait, oh--GAAHH!!

In the end all my patience and clicking paid off. By the time the session was over, i really felt like I was making a difference and hopefully aiding the researchers in their goal to help injured kids. Also, I got $150 worth of banana-scented target gift cards [insert any Flava Flav quote here]. The highlight of the day was getting to see a picture of my own brain. It was really trippy. The technician said that I had many folds in my cortex, which apparently means that I'm very creative. She was probably just being complementary to make up for sealing me in a cold, metal chamber for an hour, but I'll take it either way.

TECHNOLOGY!!!

Computers are not my friend. Ever since the 4th grade when my family's 90's era PC deleted my ENTIRE Kansas project right before the deadline, computers and I have been sworn enemies. In recent history, computers and I have negotiated a fragile truce with the advent of the mac. For the technologically challenged like me, they make it much easier to share my every thought with the world wide web. Especially now, in a world of online schools and facebook creepin', it is important that I remain somewhat informed on the inner workings of the internet. Hopefully computers and I can forge a new accord over blogspot.